Last update makes it always use food when crafting, and always use cordial when gathering. Before this it was safe to have some food or codials in your bag and just have the options unselected on lower end stuff, no longer the case.
Ok, did more fiddling with it. Set it from none to Aldgoat Milk let it use one, then back to none and it doesn't seem to be eating food anymore. Still unable to find a way to get it to reset to not using cordials.
Looks like it was a setting that just got stuck, I turned it off and on and gathered in between, after a few attempts it seems to have cleared. Maybe client crashed while I was changing something once and messed up a setting somewhere.